• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant: A Taste of Italy in Westbury

At Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, tradition meets flavor in a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Nestled in Westbury, NY, this Italian eatery is beloved for its extensive menu featuring everything from classic pizzas to hearty baked pastas. The warm ambiance complements the well-executed dishes, including the crowd-favorite Margherita pizza and delectable homemade lasagna. With options for everyone, including vegetarians, Mama Theresa's promises a delightful dining experience, whether dining in or taking out. The friendly staff ensures a memorable visit, making it a go-to spot for families and casual dates alike. Come for the food, stay for the welcoming vibe!

Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant at a glance

  • Address 1071 Old Country Rd Westbury, NY 11590 United States
  • Phone (516) 334-3334
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Elizabeth Garrett
5

First time eating in. We normally take out. The food was excellent. The zucchini chips were excellent as was the chicken Ceasar salad was more than enough. My husband enjoyed the veal marsala. The portion was enough to take home and have for lunch the next day. We will definitely return.

Diana B
4

It was a good place and I'll definitely go back. We went on a Saturday night and they were really busy. We sat on the side closet to the front door and while it was nice being able to sit quickly, but sometimes we felt a little forgotten. I had the gnocchi pesto and it was good, but it could have been better for me. Personally, I like a little more sauce and smaller gnocchi. My friend had the rigatoni florentina and it was delicious. My cesar salad also needed a little more sauce. But overall, great experience and will definitely go back.

Kevin Cullen
5

First time here. The two of us got the lunch special, Ceasar salad and chicken with broccoli rabe panini . Fantastic food and service with a smile.

Lou Cap
4

A combination pizza place / restaurant. Highly recommended for your dining pleasure. A very comfortable dining area that can accommodate any type of gathering or party. The service in the dining room is good. The menu provides many good choices, and the meals served were all perfect. You will not be disappointed and will enjoy your time here.

Kimberly Rodriguez
5

Came here for dinner with the family and everything was great. The service was exceptional. The staff treats their customers right and are very attentive. When they see you run out of complimentary bread they bring some more out. I got the buffalo pizzeta which is a "personal pizza"- and the reason why I use air quotes is because it's enough to feed at least 2 people. Maybe 3 depending on the appetite...which Hey I'm not complaining. I walked out of there with 2 days lunch. I wasn't a big fan of the leftover taste of the pizza but it's leftovers so. The rest of the family was pleased with what they ordered and had not complaints. One of the dishes was the fried chicken club which had lettuce, tomatoes, Mayo and Italian dressing. Another one was penne a la vodka but if you want chicken you have to pay extra. Then the other one was baked zitti.

David S
5

Guaranteed to enjoy your meal at Mama T's! Whether here or in East Meadow, you will not be disappointed. Very nice atmosphere, clean and neatly decorated a step above your typical pizzeria. This trip was just a couple slices, regular and Sicilian, both were cooked perfect... Excellent! Their entrees are all delicious as well. A must try. lmk what you think?

Jacqueline Vita
5

There are several Mama Theresa's on Long Island; however, this one remains my favorite. The chef and cooks here are expert in making 25 varieties of pizza and every dish on their menu. My favorite is no longer on the menu, but if you ask for their Hot Antipasto dish, you will be rewarded. Upon the platter are mozzarella sticks, baked clams, eggplant rollatini, stuffed mushrooms, and shrimp oreganata. It is flavorful and generous in portions offering you a worthy bread soak up. Another menu item I especially enjoy is their Chicken Valdostana. It is excellent in taste and in the presentation. The chicken breast is moist and crispy on the edges. The stuffing of spinach and mozzarella is enhanced by the mushroom and Marsala wine brown sauce. Decadently rich, it is one you made need another day to finish as entrees come with a choice of garden salad or pasta. For an extra fee, you can add a variety of substitutions. There are a few other dishes on the menu with this delicious brown sauce too. The Chicken Verdi is egg battered instead of bread crumbs and has a light lemon & butter sauce with either spinach or broccoli with melted mozzarella. This, too is another favorite. Whatever you delight if you visit here, it will be hard not to pass the front end counters without ordering an item as an appetizer from there or to take home for later. This is an excellent time to dine out and give the cookie baker in your family a night out!

Farhan Syed
5

This spot serves Pizzas with the true Italian taste! Perfect crisp with adequate amount of Cheese on the slice! The Owner is a gentleman too. I would recommend anyone to visit this place if you are craving for the perfect Pizza! Keep it up

Location

  • Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
    Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
    1071 Old Country Rd Westbury, NY 11590 United States Hotline: (516) 334-3334

Welcome to Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, a charming gem nestled at 1071 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY. This Italian pizzeria stands out with its rich array of authentic dishes and a warm, inviting ambiance, making it perfect for casual outings or family dinners. Whether you're a local or just visiting, Mama Theresa's promises a culinary journey filled with nostalgic flavors of traditional Italian cuisine.

This delightful establishment boasts a robust menu that caters to all palates. From their signature pizzas to hearty platters, you can expect nothing short of excellence. Highlights include the mouthwatering Meatball Parmigiana Platter and the ever-popular Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana, both served with generous portions that ensure you leave satisfied. For lighter options, the Caesar Salad and Mediterranean Salad are fresh, vibrant, and full of flavor—perfect for a midday refreshment or as a side dish with your meal.

The pizza is, of course, the star of the show here. Guests rave about the freshness of the ingredients and the traditional methods used to perfect each slice. The Margherita pizza and chicken Marsala slice are customer favorites, lauded for their balance of flavors and rich, satisfying crust. You can even enjoy a slice or two with a nice pour of the house wine, further enhancing your dining experience.

Mama Theresa’s embraces inclusivity with its extensive vegetarian options, making it a great spot for everyone. The restaurant's casual atmosphere, combined with attentive service, creates a welcoming environment for families and friends alike. As one diner noted, the staff is both warm and knowledgeable, eager to guide you through their extensive menu.

Aside from the delectable food, patrons appreciate the tidy and clean environment, which extends even to the restrooms—a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to providing a pleasant dining experience. Whether you dine in or opt for takeout, every meal is prepared with care and attention.

Planning a special gathering? Mama Theresa’s also offers catering services, ensuring your events are filled with delicious Italian fare that will impress your guests. With outdoor seating available, you can enjoy your meal al fresco on those beautiful days, making the atmosphere even more charming.

If you’re in search of a restaurant that feels like a home away from home, look no further than Mama Theresa’s Pizzeria & Restaurant. It's a place where delicious food meets friendly service, creating memories worth savoring. So grab your family, invite your friends, and come experience the flavors of Italy right here in Westbury!

For more information or to make a reservation, call (516) 334-3334. Good food and a welcoming atmosphere await you at Mama Theresa's!